|
"a fish, a barrel, and a smoking gun" |
||
|
Republican or Democrat, white or black, there's a pretty fair consensus that this is one sorry-ass nation. As in: That syphilis experiment? Sorry, our bad! We ignored your genocide? We'll do marginally better next time! Bombed your embassy? You'd better put some ice on
that! Clintonian diplomatic hallmark - i.e., Hallmark diplomacy - as a reflection of the mass psyche of the baby boomers or of the waning of personal responsibility in Marv Albert's America. But more important than either of those, it's the cheap fix of the post-New-Deal era that makes Reinventing Government look profligate. Transgressions that once might have cost billions in reparations now can be remedied for the price of a rent-a-podium and a bit of stationery. With the ascendency of Blue Mountain
Arts out altogether. notwithstanding, "sorry" seems to be not only the easiest word but the cheapest; and thus, it was only a matter of time until someone applied this pennywise discovery to the ever-econo-minded sphere of syndicated television. The squawk genre, dealing with the antipathy fatigue of an over-Springered public, has been shoehorning its material into the game show-like formats of Loveline, The Blame Game, and Change of Heart, but perhaps the savviest entrant is Fox Television's Forgive or Forget. This Theatre of Apology is firmly yet gushingly presided over by Mother Love, a matronly welfare mother turned bus driver turned therapist-cum-religious figure. (The guests insert her name with eerie devotion into every other sentence: "Well, Mother Love, I've been a bigamist for eight years.") A guest tells his, but usually her, story, which is overheard by a confessee. We can see her, but more often him, on a big-screen TV set in a yard sale-style picture frame. Then the confessor stands before a giant door and receives a judgment. (A Kafka scholar could have a field day with this.)
If the confessee is there when the door opens, forgiveness is granted. If not, not. And as mawkish as the device is, the cold, unpitying spectacle of an empty doorway is truly gut-wrenching. Or it would be, anyway, if most of the guests actually seemed remorseful, which, naturally, they don't. Classicist yet timely, Forgive showcases not so much apologies as apologias: the bulk of its guests show up to defend themselves. Their apologies boil down to: I'm sorry you're such an asshole. Many don't ask forgiveness at all. One demands that her live-in lover and father of her three (going on four) children marry her. Another insists that her husband give her a second honeymoon after a disastrous first spent sleeping on her sister-in-law's couch. The apologies we do hear are minimasterpieces of backhanded denial - "I apologize. I tried to make up for it. We have a beautiful house. You haven't had to work for five out of six years we've been married. But, you know, I apologize" - and passive-aggressive victim-blaming: "I was afraid to ask her to forgive me. I thought she'd cut me off again, Mother Love." Indeed, the genius and redeeming value of Forgive or Forget is that it proves the persistence of a certain American dignity. You can get someone to air a homosexual crush to a homicidal object of affection. Or you can give them the stage to show off their giant altered breasts or their giant unaltered guts, their love children and their multiple wives/cousins/ teenage-midget-pornographer-uncles. But good luck finding someone to go on TV to be truly sorry about anything. (Undoubtably the lack of anonymity must hurt. The late conceptual artist Allan Bridge did a much brisker business getting New Yorkers to admit to molestation, even murder, on his no-names-needed Apology Line.) Forgive has dealt with the contrition gap admirably, soliciting future guests with topics appealing not to the repentant but to the pissed-off ("You used me for sex! Now apologize!") or lovelorn ("Roommate, I want you!"). It's added a Confession Booth feature - with an unacknowledged debt to media hoaxer Joey Skaggs - where New Yorkers line up on 42nd Street to get on TV and 'fess up to penny sins like cheating on their diets and scamming US$5 from their children (whether this is a sadder commentary on contemporary modesty or the New
Times Square segment even attracts repeat visitors on the frequent-absolution plan, who seem to fancy themselves Mother Love's beloved co-stars.
But Forgive's most ingenious innovation is bringing dysfunction TV into the biotech age: Some weeks, nearly every episode includes a paternity test. Mom, often with kid in tow, cops to the relevant infidelity - there are a lot of one-night-stand pregnancies among these fecund guests - while Dad (or not) waits for the centrifuge's Solomonic verdict. Considering that advertisers long ago realized the edge-of-your-seat immediacy of pregnancy tests, even filming actual tests for commercials, it's surprising that no one has thought to marshal the ever-increasing variety of medical tests, which have all the elements of classical drama built-in: suspense, life versus death, free will versus fate. After all, if Sophocles could make a seminal work of drama out of sex and clouded paternity, why couldn't KingWorld milk a half-hour game show from it? We have a populace of underinsured who can't afford basic medical care, as well as a home audience willing to waste hours watching that same demographic bitch-slap one another on camera. Even online-porn magnate Seth Warshavsky has acknowledged the can't-miss eyeball appeal of free online surgery. Why not serve everyone's needs with free hospital access for anyone willing to get their cancer-gene, chlamydia, or Tay-Sachs results on the air?
This scheme, at least, would do someone some objective good, which is more than one can say for many of Forgive's sessions. Editing a special Apology issue of Civilization, Deborah Tannen, the PBS donor's John Gray, suggests the vogue for apology might be a corrective to the (book plug coming!) Argument Culture, a necessary first step toward healing. It'd be interesting to see what Tannen would make of a recent episode, where a young woman wrenchingly apologized to her briefly cuckolded boyfriend and asked him to be a father to her baby, who she believed was really his - so much so that she took a paternity test. The answer: No dice. It was another one-hit wonder. Upon hearing the news, the young man thanked his lazy sperm and wished her a good life. As she sobbed herself raw and then numbly took in Mother Love's parting homily ("Honey, you got to be strong for that baby"), you could already see her becoming a hardened, bitter woman, facing a sleepless future of diapers and bills. There may have been a lesson learned; she may have grown up a little. But probably not. She did what wealthier, more powerful people sham on Larry King: asked for mercy and left herself open for punishment. And her prize was 18 years of kid-shackled poverty. That may be why few people come to Forgive for forgiveness: Psychically and materially, they can't afford to. It's easy to repent in a speech or a memoir, when there's no one to answer or respond on cue. It's easy to ask for an apology or restitution; if you get turned down, it only proves how right you were. Really asking forgiveness requires admitting the possibility of rejection and censure and, perhaps, recognizing that you have done the unforgivable. But much worse, it requires accepting your answer and shutting the fuck up about it. And that, on daytime television as in life, is truly a bitch, Mother Love. courtesy of Joe Shlabotnik |
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
||