"a fish, a barrel, and a smoking gun" |
Screaming Trees Revisited
There will always be at least as many Internet-related print magazines as there are commercial online services. As long as the mags are willing to ship in poly-bags with accompanying demo disks, that is. Which may be fortuitous, considering the general vapidity of content to be found in the current crop of Internet culture rags - at least the disks provide an escape hatch. We hear those AOL chat rooms can be...rewarding.
A few years back, ultra-low-creativity CD-ROM developers were releasing horridly vacuous discs supposedly aimed at the children's market. Today's digital opportunists are jumping on the newbie gravy train, offering their poorly-informed takes on the "Information Superhighway." (We predict the hot trend of '96 to be CD-ROM-based net-focused digizines aimed at kids. It's just too backwards an idea to be left alone.)
The modus operandi of these print publications is to offer the same entry-level facts and definitions month after month, counting on a constant supply of starry-eyed net freshmen who just need to know some of the basics, like Yahoo's URL or, um, Yahoo's URL - undoubtedly related to the "churn" rate at some of our favorite online ventures. This target audience's understanding of the net starts and finishes with Sandra
Bullock not apt to disabuse them of this illusion. For your amusement and edification, Suck has rounded up the most conspicuous offenders from the newsstand, dutifully perused each from cover-to- cover, and now offers you a convenient guide to understanding the philosophy and methodology of the new breed of digerati-wannabes. Granted, ours is by-no-means comprehensive sample, but we missed the industry freebie subscription deals and happen to be working on a vacuum-tight budget, so give us a break.
VirtualCity, Fall 95 Price: $2.95, no freebie Radical Concept: "We decry the belief of some fringe geek groups that the interactive world is for radicals and nerds." (p. 4) <10-Word Lowdown: Entertainment Weekly for the AOL Set. Web Site: http://www.virtcitnow.com/
It's a safe bet that many contemporary Internet overachievers will find themselves rewarded with a fleeting taste of fame, if only because there'll always be a market for manufacturing and exploiting celebrity. VirtualCity's cover, with its collage of megastars united only by the fact that none of them would be caught dead wasting time on the net (except for Courtney Love, perhaps, but she don't know better), beckoned to us from the most appropriate of outlets: an airport newsstand. And like most airplane-suitable publications, we were finished "reading" it before the plane left the ground...
The Net, October 95 Price: $6.95 with free copy of Spry Mosaic sw Radical Concept: "22 Words/Phrases We HATE* ...(*Even if we use some of them sometimes)" (p.22) <10-Word Lowdown: Bought Emigre's Library and They're Not Afraid to Abuse It. Web Site: http://www.thenet-usa.com/
.net's sister publication, The
Net the way Suck is for original similes. Regrettably, the hackneyed cyber-by-numbers design doesn't do much to mask the fact that the think pieces need a but more thunk, and the how-to guides might want to make a stab at actually explaining something instead of digressing into perplexing diary entries.
Internet World, October 95 Price: $4.95 with free copy of Compuserve sw Radical Concept: "The burgeoning Internet market has made the Internet itself a subject worth pursuing." (p.4) <10-Word Lowdown: Someday They'll Be Bigger Than TV Guide. Web Site: http://www.iw.com/iw/
The people behind Internet World may not be obsessed with avowing a unique viewpoint, but they're thorough as hell. Which is not to say that they don't have a few competent writers - Eric Berlin and Senior Editor Andrew Kantor are experienced surfers and they let it show. But if articles with an average of three URLs per paragraph gives you a cyberwoody, why wouldn't you just opt for their page on the undeniably useful, though equally rote, MecklerWeb site?
NetGuide, October 95 Price: $2.95 with free copy of AOL sw Radical Concept: "Road Map To Win95 Internet Connectivity: A Step-by-Step..." (p. 97) <10-Word Lowdown: Catering to the PC Market is not Narrowcasting. Web Site: http://techweb.cmp.com/techweb/ng/
So what if the bulk of NetGuide's reviews read suspiciously like regurgitated press releases? At least they've got the keen business acumen to realize that an Internet magazine aimed at Windows enthusiasts will not only open them up to a huge potential subscription base, but suggests a pragmatic formula as well: a litany of features aimed at offering detailed instructions on setting up apps that were supposed to be, but (surprise!) never were, the very definition of no-brainers. How they failed to edit Larry "HTML
Manual Of Style" Aronson's on the "evolution" (read: Balkanization) of HTML "programming" into a pitchpiece for MSN is beyond us... maybe they're not a Microsoft front, after all.
Online Access, October 95 Price: $4.95 with free copy of Prodigy sw Radical Concept: "World Wide Web. E-mail. Internet. Information Superhighway. Everyone seems to be using these words lately." (p.37) <10-Word Lowdown: Tax Write-Off. Web Site: http://www.oamag.com/online/
This magazine is so thoroughly directed towards, and created by, the clueless that any degree of criticism would be missing the point. Which is ironic, considering that makes them precisely the ones least likely to ever have a chance of putting the screws to us for the slam we could so effortlessly scrawl. However, we can't resist reprinting the following inopportune quote (which, incidentally, comes only a few sentences after a review of Word entitled, without a hint of sarcasm, "Highbrow Reading"): "By the time you read this, the Utne Reader will be up and running on the Web at http://www.utne.com. Dubbing itself, 'a quality filter for the infoweary,' the online version is likely to be a hit with its current cybersavvy print readership." Needless to say, the moment any of the above magazines dedicates attention and a healthy helping of column inches to Suck, they become peerlessly savvy in our book. Sadly, we may never blip the radar of most of the these rags, and the others will have gone bankrupt by the time word would've gotten around. Maybe by the time the next round of cyber-lifestyle guides gets start-up capital, we'll have become jaded enough to grab a Dvorak-style column in one or two. If it weren't for our knack for burning bridges... Still, even if we're ostracized from the net publishing community, there's nothing stopping you from putting to use the insights you may have gleaned from our study. Used wisely, the information provided here may help guide you towards a lucrative contract with AOL, Compuserve, or Prodigy to provide glorified packaging for their next software release, in the form of an Internet culture mag of your very own! courtesy of the Duke of URL
| |
![]() |